The myth of Haiti’s lawless streets
To withhold aid because of the ‘security situation’ is a miserable excuse for agencies’ failure to deliver desperately needed help
By Inigo Gilmore | The Guardian | January 20, 2010
A man carries an injured child in Port-au-Prince, Haiti, six days after the earthquake.
Photograph: Emiliano Larizza/Contrasto / eyevine
As a member of the media covering the tragedy in Haiti, it’s with a sense of alarm and astonishment that I’ve witnessed how some senior aid officials have argued for withholding aid of the utmost urgency because of sensational claims about violence and insecurity, which appear to be based more on fantasy than reality.
John O’Shea, who runs the well-known Irish aid agency Goal, has joined this chorus, telling the Guardian he couldn’t get his trucks from the Dominican Republic to Haiti because he had no guarantees his drivers wouldn’t be “macheted to death on the way down”. He added that Goal has no plans to deploy its much-needed doctors and nurses on the streets of Port-au-Prince.
From what I’ve observed, such chilling claims do not match the reality on the ground; and by trumpeting a distorted and sensational picture about the violence, some senior aid officials may be culpable of undermining the very aid effort they are supposed to be promoting. When I traveled into Haiti’s disaster zone last week from the Dominican Republic, I did so alone and on a bus, whose passengers were mostly Haitians, including some living in the US. Since then, whether on the road to Port-au-Prince or within the city, I have not witnessed anyone wielding a gun, a machete or a club of any kind. Nor have I witnessed an act of violence. (I have seen one badly wounded man who had been shot in circumstances which were unclear and who was eventually rescued by US soldiers after an American reporter sought help.)
Any violence is localised and sporadic; the situation is desperate yet not dangerous in general. Crucially, it’s not a war zone; it’s a disaster zone – and there appears to have been little attempt to distinguish carefully between destructive acts of criminality and the behaviour of starving people helping themselves to what they can forage. For Haitians and many of those trying to help them, the overriding sentiment is that a massive catastrophe on this scale shouldn’t have to wait for aid because blanket security is the absolute priority.
Moreover hundreds of journalists, volunteers from churches and private individuals have traveled in from the Dominican Republic, some of them bringing in desperately needed aid. From what I know, not a single person who has attempted to provide assistance to the people of Port-au-Prince, including medics, has run into any serious trouble.
En route to Port-au-Prince I met David Pierre-Louis, a 31-year-old Haitian-American, who had come to find his mother and bring much needed medical supplies. Happily, he found her alive and well, and later, she and a local nurse used the medicine David brought all the way from Seattle to set up a makeshift clinic on a street near her shattered home.
David, who runs a jazz club in Seattle, is now trying to fill the void by sending in his own medical supplies paid for by donations from the Haitian-American community and other concerned Americans. He told me:
“Haitians here cannot understand why they’re not getting help, especially as the way the violence is portrayed is not right. The people are unhappy that there’s been no assistance but do you see them rioting in the streets? No.
“People are hungry and needy and yet they’re being portrayed as savages. Aid is not getting there quick enough and that’s sad because the solution is right there and we have the power to do it.”
John O’Shea has shown in the past that his aid agency has the power to do it. Yet this time, while the Irish people have generously donated more than 1m euros to Goal for their Haiti operations, the agency has yet to swing into action. While announcing that they hope to start some limited food distribution in one location in Port-au-Prince, O’Shea is insisting on a change in the security situation first before their operation can be rolled out, medics and all.
There are some real security issues in Port-au-Prince but some of the more alarming images and incidents portrayed in the media must be seen for what they are, and in context. Reports about marauding, machete-wielding gangs taking over Port-au-Prince are very wide of the mark. The people are welcoming and helpful to those who come to help them and, if anything, go out of their way to ensure you are safe.
Last weekend, in the park near the destroyed presidential palace, which has become a makeshift refugee camp for tens of thousands, we meet three Cuban doctors and nurses. They were working alone, without an escort, and they were treating a large group of injured men women and children, who calmly waited their turn. That night, on the other side of the park, I saw a group of homeless queueing patiently to collect water in plastic containers. No one was harassing them, and there was no sign of any of the criminal gangs that supposedly now rule the streets.
I can see no reason why, with some concerted pressure and a little coordination, aid agencies like Goal cannot deploy securely into the heart of Port–au-Prince, with their clinics and food distribution outlets. With thousands of the injured living in close quarters at makeshift camps, the rapid deployment of medical care is still paramount.
Of all the disasters I’ve covered in recent years, the response to this has perhaps been the most perplexing, and disastrous in itself. From the Haitian perspective, if anyone is dragging their feet it’s the aid agencies. One thing is clear: if aid agencies do not quickly roll out a coordinated and comprehensive response, then not only will many more die, but the deteriorating security situation, which is being talked up so much, may perhaps become a self-fulfilling prophecy.
So John O’Shea, if you are reading this, I put down this challenge to you: if you are prepared, in the next few days, to bring an aid van or truck to the Dominican/Haitian border, I will travel with it into Port-au-Prince. I will even help you to distribute the aid.
The Haitian people need help now, not excuses.
Thank you for the new perspective. And to imagine we Americans have people trampled to death just trying to get into rock concerts and Walmarts.
LikeLike
Comment by wilf | January 21, 2010 |
John Shea is probably repeating what he was told by US military. They’re using fear to control him. Just as the US regime uses fear to control its 300 million domestic slaves.
US military is not in Haiti to distribute aid. US military is in Haiti to control the distribution of aid.
Again the empire strikes.
LikeLike
Comment by Joe Gall | January 21, 2010 |
I guess there is a need to ratchet up tensions to justify America”s long term occupation of the island for geo-political reasons – Cuba is next door and Venezuela, where the Russians have been offered use of an airbase, is to the south, coupled with the gold, oil and other valuable minerals awaiting exploitation by US corporations which would be helped by a large pool of cheap labour.
The earthquake has been a fortuitous opportunity for a peaceful’invasion’ by US forces ostensibly to help the Haitians who have been shafted over the years by unfriendly US policies. US forces seem to be hindering rather than facilitating the distribution of aid judging from the muffled howls of frustration coming from some of its allies whose priority is humanitarian assistance rather than geopolitical advantage. I think it is Obama’s Chief of Staff who said ”Never allow a crisis to go to waste”. In other words, use a crisis as an opportunity to achieve other objectives.
Although GOAL complains about the Chinese trading with African nations without querying their human rights record, I can find no such complaints about the bribery and corruption, human rights abuses and ineffective aid to Iraq and Afghanistan that followed America and her allies illegal wars against those countries. I am not much impressed with anyone who thinks that what is sauce for the goose is not also sauce for the gander.
LikeLike
Comment by Truthteller | January 21, 2010 |
Other articles are emerging about possible large Oil fields in Haiti, and how they have been un-exploited for decades. Puts the military force on the ground in a whole new light.
LikeLike
Comment by Andy Priester | January 21, 2010 |
[…] The myth of Haiti’s lawless streets « Aletho News. January 21st, 2010 | Category: Uncategorized | Leave a comment | […]
LikeLike
Pingback by The Progressive Mind » The myth of Haiti’s lawless streets « Aletho News | January 21, 2010 |
Well, now that the gloves are off and the U.S.S.A. has found out about the huge oil reserves off Haiti, it’s not a surprise that the military is there denying food to people and shooting teenage girls in the head for stealing five bucks worth of shitty pictures.
I can imagine how stupid fucking amerkan’s would react if their teenage children were shot in the head for stealing PEZ from the local convenience store..
it’s all for oil. and cheap labor. the U.S.S.A. is worse than the nazi axis ever dreamt of, and then some.
LikeLike
Comment by HUGE OIL RESERVE OFF HAITI | January 21, 2010 |
I’ve been closely watching the emotive pleas and utterances of Mr O’Shea since I noticed his outspoken insistence that the US step-in and ‘help’ in the Sudan. He has also denigrated the people of Somalia. I suspect Mr O’Shea to be quite willing to advance the cause of liberal ‘intervention’ at every opportunity. I no longer trust that Mr O’Shea operates from truly humanitarian motives, for if he does he must be one of the most naive humanitarians on the planet.
LikeLike
Comment by Hubris | January 21, 2010 |
The commentary about oil reserves serves only as a distraction. There are untapped deep water oil reserves all over the place, the rationales regarding oil that have been put forward are incoherent.
What we do know for a fact is that within weeks of raising the minimum wage both Aristide and Zelaya were deposed. We should stick to the facts when attempting to ascertain motives, otherwise we are just swinging blindly.
LikeLike
Comment by aletho | January 21, 2010 |
[…] https://alethonews.wordpress.com/2010/01/21/the-myth-of-haitis-lawless-streets/ (LINK) Tagged with: Aid earthquake Haiti […]
LikeLike
Pingback by The myth of Haiti’s lawless streets - Montpelier | January 21, 2010 |
Thanks for a new perspective. It is beginning to look more like an invasion by the US Empire precipitated by the HAARP earthquake weapon. 20,000 American troops??? No wonder no aid for Haitians can get through, when you have to supply that many soldiers. At least, Israel’s IDF is taking full advantage and is harvesting organs fulltime.
LikeLike
Comment by Miguel Grande | January 22, 2010 |
[…] The myth of Haiti’s lawless streets […]
LikeLike
Pingback by Haiti Update: The News That’s Not On Your TV « Hope2012 | January 22, 2010 |
“It all comes probably from your colleagues, who present Haiti in the light of violence and laziness, at least those who work for large media companies which form a negative public opinion about Haitians. In my article http://fountaineers.blogsite.org/2010/01/17/haitians-victims-or-survivors-what-matters-is-how-we-are-presented-with-facts/ I showed an example how it works and what for ….
Thank you for sharing! We would need more reporters who present ALL sides of the situation
LikeLike
Comment by boomerangblogger | January 23, 2010 |
[…] The myth of Haiti’s lawless streets […]
LikeLike
Pingback by Haiti-wood, U.S.A. « F*ck Politics | January 24, 2010 |